Filter bubbles

From Red House Wiki
Revision as of 12:36, 22 November 2018 by Gav (Talk | contribs)

Jump to: navigation, search
Filterbubbles.jpg

Filter bubbles or echo chambers are what happens when the information you come across reflects your personal history so well that you stop learning anything new. They're a big problem in Knowledge Management.

They reflect self-reinforcing positive feedbacks, that accelerate as they converge on a fixed point. On the plus side, they act to split areas of convergence from one another, increase precision and generate heterogeneity in information flow. But like black holes, they're difficult to escape from.

In natural systems, these positive feedbacks are held in check by opposing mixing processes, which cause divergence instead of convergence, spreading flows out instead of concentrating them. Filter bubbles emerge when those spreading processes are relatively ineffective and so convergence comes to dominate the flow.

Up to a point, you could regard filter bubbles as a natural response to enormous flows passing through parts of the internet. But filter bubbles are not necessarily the most productive or efficient way to accommodate that flow, and clearly they have other important consequences too (e.g. political).

At least part of the reason for relatively weak mixing on the internet is that algorithmic methods tend to chase marginal improvements in precision, using relatively fixed social and taxonomic data with low degrees of freedom as a conduit. Another is that information providers sometimes build very complex systems (e.g. to include more "intelligence"), and often, this can't keep up with rapidly changing flows.

But there are relatively simple ways around some of these things, more in line with balanced natural systems (for example, better use of clickstream data or better design of negative feedbacks), so I expect that filter bubbles are not the end of the story.

{!ctf} is all about balancing divergence and convergence to optimise things.

Related Pages

 Collaborative filtering Bottom-up Related Pages
 Knowledge Management Information diet Personal Recommendations
 Positive feedback Making it more useful Monitoring the school's progress
 Simple population model Artificial Intelligence Machine learning